` Net Neutrality | Jeremy Gilbert : Design Thinker, Professor and Multimedia Journalist

Posts Tagged ‘Net Neutrality’

Who pays for AT&T’s home mini-tower

Tuesday, April 6th, 2010

On the same day that a Federal Court struck down the FCC’s right to regulate broadband traffic AT&T has introduced its mini-tower.

AT&T Mini-Towers can extend the AT&T wireless signal via your home network, but you have to pay for the privilege.

The mini-tower is an ingenious little device that boost AT&T’s weak network coverage by translating the cell phone signal and transmitting information over a user’s home network network instead of relying on AT&T’s balky towers. This concept isn’t unique to AT&T (Sprint and Verizon also offer similar services) but astoundingly consumers not only pay for the bandwidth, the cell minutes (which still count against monthly totals) and also $150 for the device.

This new system puts broadband Internet providers, like the cable companies and actually AT&T, in an interesting position. Why should they have to cover the cost of sending AT&T voice signals over their networks? This is not a problem if AT&T is both the consumers cellular and broadband supplier. But since a Federal court struck down the FCC’s right to enforce net neutrality — the principle that broadband suppliers would have to carry all data at the same rate — Comcast or other broadband providers appear to have the right limit bandwidth used by AT&T mini-towers.

Maybe AT&T’s greed in both charging consumers and using their broadband access instead of providing a working cellular network will end up being a good thing… if it forces AT&T to support net neutrality.

If You Post a Story and No Search Bot Finds It…

Wednesday, January 6th, 2010

In the first meeting of my Journalism & Technology practicum a student asked an interesting question: ‘What happens if you publish a story that the search engines don’t find or ignore?’

At the time I didn’t really appreciate the full implications of the question. But later that evening on the phone with a reporter asking about Pay Walls I started to wonder: As much as we concern ourselves with Net Neutrality, should we be equally concerned about Search Engine Neutrality?

What will happen if Microsoft’s Bing search engine really does pay Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp. for exclusive access to his company’s news content? Will Bing weigh stories from USA Today, the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal equally? If I paid millions for the right to include the Wall Street Journal in my search results I might weight that more heavily. What about similar stories from the New York Post and the Daily News?

I am not excited about a world in which the search engines change their model from relevancy to exclusive partnerships. This may not be very different from what the Satellite and Cable operators do, but that model doesn’t work well for consumers either. And access to out of region NFL games seems less important to democracy than access to a variety of voices around important news stories.

Improve the web with Nofollow Reciprocity.